User:公的驱逐舰/Provisional Policy/User group policy: Difference between revisions

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{Provisional Policy|type=administrator action|provisional-reason=zhpolicy|ver=3317250|translated-by=[[User:One-Six]]|checked-by=[[User:Carryye]]|approved-by=}}{{-}}
+{{Provisional Policy|type=administrator action|provisional-reason=zhpolicy|ver=4686489|translated-by=[[User:One-Six]]|checked-by=|approved-by=}}{{-}}
+'''Before further change is implemented, {{user|Etolli}} of the "Staff" functional user group will not participate in administrative works, will not be counted in voting matters, and will not be subjected to activity limitations.'''
 ==Overview==
-'''The following clause was expanded for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and may be slightly different from the original.'''
+'''The following clauses were expanded for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and may be slightly different from the original.'''
 There are two types of user groups in English Moegirlpedia.
 #'''Authoritative''' user groups (or "'''authorities'''") have some administrative rights within Moegirlpedia; their actions and comments are usually considered official actions and comments from English Moegirlpedia.
-#*Currently, only '''[[Project:bureaucrats|bureaucrats]]''', '''[[Project:administrators|administrators]]''', and '''[[Project:patroller|patroller]]s''' are considered authorities; they proceed from the most to least powerful in that order.
+#*Currently, only '''[[Project:bureaucrats|bureaucrats]]''', '''[[Project:administrators|administrators]]''', and '''[[Project:patroller|patrollers]]''' are considered authorities; they proceed from the most to least powerful in that order.
 #*The more powerful authority also has the user group status and corresponding rights from all lower power authorities. E.g. an admin also has rights of a patroller, and a bureaucrat has rights of an admin and a patroller.
 #'''Functional''' user groups (or "'''titles'''") have no administrative rights; however, they may have some nonadministrative privileges, such as having their edits automatically marked as patrolled (good editor) or the ability to use MediaWiki API to perform large amounts of automatic edits (bots). Users with title user groups are still regular users, and their actions and comments in no way represent English Moegirlpedia (unless they are also an authority).
@@ Line 23: / Line 25: @@
 ===Administrators===
-As some of the most senior editors in Moegirlpedia, administrators will be the primary maintainer of several topics, usually a collection of articles revolving a common subject (e.g. a game or an anime show), throughout the site.
+<small>Main article: [[Moegirlpedia:Administrators]]</small>
-They will build navboxes and other complicated templates, propose and maintain categories, and guide other user edits.
+As some of the most senior editors in Moegirlpedia, administrators will be the primary maintainer of several topics, usually a collection of articles revolving a common subject (e.g. a game or an anime show), throughout the site. They will build navboxes and other complicated templates, propose and maintain categories and categorization systems, and guide other user edits.
-Admins will handle controversial, divisive, and sensitive issues should they arise.
+Admins will handle controversial, divisive, and sensitive issues should they arise; they will also participate in discussions throughout Moegirlpedia, notably in the [[Talk:Discussion board|Discussion board]], and be the moderator of these discussions. Also, Admins will participate in votes that will decide the composition of the authorities and the rules or the future of Moegirlpedia.
-They will also participate in discussions throughout Moegirlpedia, notably in the [[Talk:Discussion board|Discussion board]], and be the moderator of these discussions.
-Admins will participate in votes that will decide the rules or the future of Moegirlpedia.
 ===Patrollers===
-As experienced editors, patrollers are tasked to maintain the readability of many articles.
+<small>Main article: [[Moegirlpedia:Patroller]]</small>
-They do not have to participate in all matters throughout the site, but they should bring every page they patrolled up to par even if they have no interest in the topics in those pages.
+As moderately or highly experienced editors, patrollers are tasked to maintain the readability of articles. They do not have to participate in all matters throughout the site, but they should bring every page they patrolled up to par even if they have no interest in the topics in those pages.
 ===Good editors===
-Good editors do not have additional responsibilities save for the articles they edit.
+Good editors do not have additional responsibilities save for those regarding the articles they have edited; their edits should be free of errors (that need others to fix); they don't have to make the articles perfect, but they must bring them up to par. Good editors should leave good, helpful edit notes if needed so that others can continue to improve the article.
-Good editors' edits should be free of errors (that need others to fix); they don't have to make the articles perfect, but they must bring them up to par.
-Good editors should leave good, helpful edit notes if needed so that others can continue to improve the article.
 ==Application requirements==
@@ Line 56: / Line 50: @@
 Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:
 #'''be an active patroller''' at the time of application.
-#'''have at least 100 edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), '''at least 10 edits''' in the template namespace, and '''at least 10 edits''' in the category namespace.
+#'''have at least 600 combined edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
 #*These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
-#'''be skilled in the usage of wikitexts''', categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
+#'''be skilled in the usage of wikitexts''', categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia and have the ability to understand complicated wikitext.
-#'''be the main contributor of at least three articles''' to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write good articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+#'''be the main contributor of at least ten articles''' to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write good articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
 #'''be the main maintainer of at least one topic''' to prove the ability to organize and manage topic-level projects. These topics may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
 #'''have understanding of article organizations''' in Moegirlpedia.
 #'''have the ability to be on Moegirlpedia for at least 30 minutes per day''' to edit and maintain it.
-#'''Answer questions given by other active authorities''' about management, authority power, and future development of Moegirlpedia.
+#'''not be in active probation'''(see [[#Grounds for demotion, impeachment, and removal]] for details).
-#*the applicant can choose an arbitrary amount of questions to answer (but they must answer at least one);
+#'''have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed''' from the administrator authority, '''nor have made another application''' for such authority.
-#*the questioning authority may choose to ask additional questions when they get an answer, and the applicant can choose whether to answer the additional questions;
-#*initial questions should be submitted within 48 hours of the submission of an application, but there is no limit on answering and asking additional questions.
-'''Qualifying applicants must then pass the confirmation vote.'''
-*A vote to confirm the applicant may be started after the submission of an application. This vote lasts 7 days.
-*In an administration confirmation vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be split (e.g. they must all go to "AYE" or "NAY").
-*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, '''and''' when the ratio of participating active admins versus the number of active admins exceeds 2:3, the applicant will be confirmed; any other case results in a failed confirmation.
 ===Patrollers===
 Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:
-#'''have at least 50 edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), '''at least 1 edit''' in the template namespace, and '''at least 1 edit:'''
+#'''have read through {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patroller|萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务}}'''.
-##in the category namespace, or
+#'''have at least 200 combined edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
-##in the main namespace pertaining to the categorization of articles; this includes adding pages to a correct category or fixing incorrectly categorized pages.
 #*These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
 #'''have good knowledge of the usage of wikitexts''', categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
 #'''be the main contributor of at least one article''' to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write articles. This article may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
 #'''have at least three distinct edits that can demonstrate their ability to maintain and improve articles.''' These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+#'''have not done, in the past 30 days, any of the following''':
+#*made actions outlined in {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Blocking Guideline|萌娘百科:方针#用户封禁政策}} as grounds for blocking;
+#*made actions such as ad hominem attacks, edit wars, etc..
+#'''have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed''' from the patroller authority, '''nor have made another application''' for such authority.
+===Good editors===
+'''One do not have to apply for a good editor title''', nor is there set requirements. Administrators and patrollers may grant good editor titles at their discretion to any editors that (wait for it) make good edits that require no further patrolling or cleanup.
+==Promotion process==
+'''The following clauses were modified for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia to better suit her public discussion system.'''
+===Bureaucrats===
+Currently, the bureaucrat authority has no set promotion process.
-'''Qualifying applicants must then be confirmed by an administrator.'''
+===Administrators===
+#Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the administrator authority on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]] by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
+#*Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust and in turn enough AYE's in the confirmation vote.
+#Other active administrators may post questions about management, authority power, and future development of Moegirlpedia during the questioning period. This period is generally 7 days since the submission of the application; a bureaucrat may decide to change the length of the questioning period for each specific application at their discretion.
+#*the applicant can choose an arbitrary amount of questions to answer;
+#*the questioning authority may choose to ask additional questions when they get an answer, and the applicant can choose whether to answer the additional questions.
+#After the questioning period ends, a vote to confirm the applicant will be started by an active authority; the voting period lasts 7 days. All active authorities that participate in votes shall be pinged at the start of the vote.
+#*After the voting period ends, an active administrator shall count the vote. In an administration confirmation vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be split (e.g. they must all go to "AYE" or "NAY").
+#*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, '''and''' when the ratio of participating active admins versus the number of active admins exceeds 2:3, the applicant will be confirmed; any other case results in a failed confirmation.
+#After the voting period ends, a bureaucrat shall confirm the vote counts and the voting result and proceed with the promotion accordingly.
+Note: If a former administrator who announced voluntary leave due to personal reasons (instead of community questioning or backlash) reapplies for administrator authority within 6 months of the leave, '''a bureaucrat may choose to skip the confirmation vote and grant the admin authority promptly'''.
+===Patrollers===
+#Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the patroller authority on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]] by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
+#*Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust required to be confirmed.
+#An active administrator may review the applicant and grant the patroller authority promptly after confirming that the applicant meets requirments.
 *Remember that the administrator may deny an application even if the minimum requirements were met.
-*Note: since no vote is needed to confirm a patroller, the confirming administrator must carefully inspect the edit history of the applicant to make sure no edit wars, ad hominem attacks, or other acts disqualifying the applicant from serving as a patroller was committed by them in the past 1 month.
+====New Patroller Probation====
+#After a successful confirmation, the promoted applicant enters a 15-day '''New Patroller Probation Period''' ('''N3P'''). N3P Patrollers that have carried out expected maintenance and management workloads and met appropriate standards will, at the end of the N3P, become a formal patroller. If the applicant fails the N3P, they may not apply for patroller authority again in 30 days.
+#During N3P, the N3P patroller is treated as a member of their former user group before the promotion in promotion, impeachment, and proposal votes.
+#At the end of the N3P, the administrator responsible for the initial promotion (or, when this administrator is not available due to unforeseen circumstances, another administrator entrusted by the administrator responsible for the initial promotion or assigned by a bureaucrat) shall carry out an evaluation. The evaluation should cover these aspects:
+##Is this applicant actively participating in maintenance and management tasks and have not made major mistakes? See also {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patroller|萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务}} for reference.
+##
+##
+#If a former patroller who announced voluntary leave due to personal reasons (instead of community questioning or backlash) reapplies for patroller authority within 6 months of the leave, the administrator granting the authority may choose to skip the N3P.
+'''We return with translated text.'''
 ===Good editors===
-'''One do not have to apply for a good editor title.''' Administrators and patrollers may grant good editor titles at their discretion to any editors that (wait for it) make good edits that require no further patrolling, or cleanup.
+*Administrators or patrollers may grant this title promptly after their review.
+Note that
-If you think you are eligible for the good editor title but do not have it, apply with any authority or on the discussion board.
+*If you want to obtain this title, you may apply directly to any administrator or patroller or apply directly on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]].
+*Authorities granting good editor titles should provide accurate promotion reasons.
 ==Grounds for demotion, impeachment, and removal==

Revision as of 23:57, 23 February 2021

Overview

User group management rights

Overview of responsibilities

Administrators

Patrollers

Good editors

Application requirements

Bureaucrats

Administrators

Patrollers

Good editors

Promotion process

Bureaucrats

Administrators

Patrollers

New Patroller Probation

Good editors

Grounds for demotion, impeachment, and removal

Bureaucrats

Administrators

Patrollers

Good editors

Appendix

Voting convention

Footnotes and references