Difference between revisions of "User:公的驱逐舰/Provisional Policy/User group policy"

From Moegirlpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
m (→‎Grounds for impeachment, revocation, and removal)
m (check against latest version)
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
{{Provisional Policy|type=administrator action|provisional-reason=zhpolicy|ver=3269510 |translated-by=[[User:公的驱逐舰]]|checked-by=[[User:Carryye]]|approved-by=}}{{-}}
+
{{Provisional Policy|type=administrator action|provisional-reason=zhpolicy|ver=4996873|translated-by=[[User:One-Six]]|checked-by=|approved-by=}}{{-}}
  
 
==Overview==
 
==Overview==
−
'''The following clause was expanded for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and may be slightly different from the original.'''
+
'''Until further change is implemented, {{user|Etolli}} of the "Staff" functional user group will not participate in administrative works, will not be counted in voting matters, and will not be subjected to activity limitations.'''
 +
 
 +
'''The following clauses were expanded for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and may be slightly different from the original.'''
  
 
There are two types of user groups in English Moegirlpedia.  
 
There are two types of user groups in English Moegirlpedia.  
−
#'''Authoritative''' user groups (or "'''authorities'''") have some administrative power within Moegirlpedia; their actions and comments are usually considered official actions and comments from English Moegirlpedia.  
+
#'''Authoritative''' user groups (or "'''authorities'''") have some administrative rights within Moegirlpedia; their actions and comments are usually considered official actions and comments from Moegirlpedia.  
−
#*Currently, only '''bureaucrats''', '''administrators''', and '''patrollers''' are considered authorities; they proceed from the most to least powerful in that order.
+
#*Currently, only '''[[Project:bureaucrats|bureaucrats]]''', '''[[Project:administrators|administrators]]''', and '''[[Project:patroller|patrollers]]''' are considered authorities; they proceed from the most to least powerful in that order.
−
#*The more powerful authority also has the user group power and status from all lower power authorities (e.g. an admin also has powers of a patroller, and a bureaucrat has powers of an admin and a patroller).  
+
#*The more powerful authority also has the user group status and corresponding rights from all lower power authorities. E.g. an admin also has rights of a patroller, and a bureaucrat has rights of an admin and a patroller.
−
#'''Functional''' user groups (or "'''titles'''") have no administrative power; however, they may have some nonadministrative privileges, such as having their edits automatically marked as patrolled (good editor) or the ability to use Mediawiki API to perform large amounts of automatic edits (bots). Users with functional titles are still regular users, and their actions and comments in no way represent English Moegirlpedia (unless they are also an authority).  
+
#'''Functional''' user groups (or "'''roles'''") have no administrative rights; however, they may have some nonadministrative privileges, such as having their edits automatically marked as patrolled (good editor) or the ability to use MediaWiki API to perform large amounts of automatic edits (bots). Users with functional user groups are still regular users, and their actions and comments in no way represent English Moegirlpedia (unless they are also an authority).  
−
#*Some common titles include good editors, bots, and autoconfirmed users.
+
#*Some common roles include [[Project:Goodeditor|good editors]], [[Project:bots|bots]], and [[Project:autoconfirmed users|autoconfirmed users]].
  
 
'''We return to translated text.'''
 
'''We return to translated text.'''
  
−
==User group management power==
+
==User group management rights==
−
Detailed powers and rights of different user groups are listed in [[Special:ListGroupRights]]. Only user group management powers are briefed here.
+
Detailed rights of different user groups are listed in [[Special:ListGroupRights]]. Only user group management rights are briefed here.
  
−
*Bureaucrats may grant or remove user groups and power to or from any user (including themselves), regardless of their user group status.
+
#Bureaucrats may grant or remove any user group status to or from '''any''' user (including themselves), regardless of their user group status.
−
*Administrators may grant patroller power or good editor status.  
+
#Administrators may grant patroller or good editor status.  
−
*Patrollers may grant good editor status.
+
#Patrollers may grant good editor status.
  
−
==Responsibilities overview==
+
==Overview of responsibilities==
  
 
===Administrators===
 
===Administrators===
−
As some of the most senior editors in Moegirlpedia, administrators will be the primary maintainer of several topics, usually a collection of articles revolving a common subject (e.g. a game or an anime show), throughout the site.
+
{{Main|Moegirlpedia:Administrators}}
−
 
 
−
They will build navboxes and other complicated templates, propose and maintain categories, and guide other user edits.
 
−
 
 
−
Admins will handle controversial, divisive, and sensitive issues should they arise.
 
  
−
They will also participate in discussions throughout Moegirlpedia, notably in the [[Talk:Discussion board|Discussion board]], and be the moderator of these discussions.  
+
As some of the most senior editors in Moegirlpedia, administrators will be the primary maintainer of several topics, usually a collection of articles revolving a common subject (e.g. a game or an anime show), throughout the site. They will build navboxes and other complicated templates, propose and maintain categories and categorization systems, and guide other user edits.  
  
−
Admins will participate in votes that will decide the rules or the future of Moegirlpedia.  
+
Admins will handle controversial, divisive, and sensitive issues should they arise; they will also participate in discussions throughout Moegirlpedia, notably in the [[Talk:Discussion board|Discussion board]], and be the moderators of these discussions. Also, Admins will participate in votes that will decide the composition of the authorities and the rules or the future of Moegirlpedia.  
  
 
===Patrollers===
 
===Patrollers===
−
As experienced editors, patrollers are tasked to maintain the readability of many articles.
+
{{Main|Moegirlpedia:Patroller}}
  
−
They do not have to participate in all matters throughout the site, but they should bring every page they patrolled up to par even if they have no interest in the topics in those pages.
+
As moderately or highly experienced editors, patrollers are tasked to maintain the readability of articles. They do not have to participate in all matters throughout the site, but they should bring every page they patrolled up to par even if they have no interest in the topics in those pages.
  
 
===Good editors===
 
===Good editors===
−
Good editors do not have additional responsibilities save for the articles they edit.
+
{{Main|Moegirlpedia:Goodeditor}}
  
−
Good editors' edits should be free of errors (that needs others to fix); they don't have to make the articles perfect, but they must bring them up to par.  
+
Good editors do not have additional responsibilities save for those regarding the articles they have edited; their edits should be free of errors (that need others to fix); they don't have to make the articles perfect, but they must bring them up to par. Good editors should leave good, helpful edit notes if needed so that others can continue to improve the article.
−
 
 
−
Good editors should leave good, helpful edit notes if needed so that others can continue to improve the article.
 
  
 
==Application requirements==
 
==Application requirements==
 
'''The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.'''
 
'''The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.'''
−
*Since the user group status is currently linked interwiki-wise, English Moegirlpedia follows the Chinese Moegirlpedia application requirements.
+
*Since the user group status is currently linked interwiki-wise, English Moegirlpedia follows the Chinese Moegirlpedia application requirements. This text should be updated whenever the corresponding Chinese policy is changed.
−
'''We resume with translated text.'''
+
*"Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites" currently include English, [[:zh:Mainpage|Chinese]], and [[:ja:Mainpage|Japanese]] Moegirlpedia and [[cm:Mainpage|Moegirl Commons]] and [[library:Mainpage|Moegirl Wenku]]. This applies to the rest of this document.
 +
'''We return to translated text.'''
  
 
===Bureaucrats===
 
===Bureaucrats===
Line 55: Line 52:
 
===Administrators===
 
===Administrators===
 
Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:  
 
Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:  
−
#be a current patroller.
+
#'''be an active patroller''' at the time of application.
−
#have at least 100 edits in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), at least 10 edits in the template namespace, and at least 10 edits in the category namespace. These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.  
+
#'''have at least 600 combined edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
−
#be skilled in the usage of wikitexts, categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
+
#*These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
−
#be the main contributor of at least three articles to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write good articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.  
+
#'''be skilled in the usage of wikitexts''', categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia and have the ability to understand complicated wikitext.
−
#be the main maintainer of at least one topic to prove the ability to organize and manage topic-level projects. These topics may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+
#'''be the main contributor of at least ten articles''' to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write good articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
−
#have understanding of article organizations in Moegirlpedia.
+
#'''be the main maintainer of at least one topic''' to prove the ability to organize and manage topic-level projects. These topics may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
−
#have the ability to be on Moegirlpedia of at least 30 minutes per day to edit and maintain it.  
+
#'''have understanding of article organizations''' in Moegirlpedia.
−
#Answer questions given by other active authorities about management, authority power, and future development of Moegirlpedia.
+
#'''have the ability to be on Moegirlpedia for at least 30 minutes per day''' to edit and maintain it.
−
#*the applicant can choose an arbitrary amount of questions to answer (but they must answer at least one);
+
#'''not be in active probation'''(see [[#Grounds for demotion and removal]] for details).
−
#*the questioning authority may choose to ask additional questions when they get an answer, and the applicant can choose whether to answer the additional questions;
+
#'''have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed''' from the administrator authority, '''nor have made another application''' for such authority.
−
#*initial questions should be submitted within 48 hours of the submission of an application, but there is no limit on answering and asking additional questions.  
+
 
 +
===Patrollers===
 +
Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:
 +
#'''have read through {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patroller|萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务}}'''.
 +
#'''have at least 200 combined edits''' in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
 +
#*These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
 +
#'''have good knowledge of the usage of wikitexts''', categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
 +
#'''be the main contributor of at least one article''' to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write articles. This article may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
 +
#'''have at least three distinct edits that can demonstrate their ability to maintain and improve articles.''' These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
 +
#'''have not done, in the past 30 days, any of the following''':
 +
#*made actions outlined in {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Block Policy|萌娘百科:方针#用户封禁政策}} as grounds for blocking;
 +
#*made actions such as ad hominem attacks, edit wars, etc..
 +
#'''have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed''' from the patroller authority, '''nor have made another application''' for such authority.
 +
 
 +
===Good editors===
 +
'''One do not have to apply for a good editor role''', nor is there set requirements. Administrators and patrollers may grant good editor roles at their discretion to any editors that (wait for it) make good edits that require no further patrolling or cleanup.
 +
 
 +
==Promotion process==
 +
'''The following clauses were modified for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia to better suit her public discussion system.'''
 +
 
 +
===Bureaucrats===
 +
Currently, the bureaucrat authority has no set promotion process.
 +
 
 +
===Administrators===
 +
#Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the administrator authority on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]] by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
 +
#*Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust and in turn enough AYE's in the confirmation vote.
 +
#Other active administrators may post questions about management, authority power, and future development of Moegirlpedia during the questioning period. This period is generally 7 days starting from the submission of the application; a bureaucrat may change the length of the questioning period for each specific application at their discretion.
 +
#*the applicant can choose an arbitrary amount of questions to answer;
 +
#*the questioning authority may choose to ask additional questions when they get an answer, and the applicant can choose whether to answer the additional questions.
 +
#After the expiry of the questioning period, a vote to confirm the applicant will be started by an active authority; the voting period lasts 7 days. All active authorities that participate in votes shall be pinged at the start of the vote.
 +
#*After the voting period ends, an active administrator shall count the vote. In an administration confirmation vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be split (e.g. they must all go to "AYE" or "NAY").
 +
#*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, '''and''' when the ratio of participating active admins versus the number of active admins exceeds 2:3, the applicant will be confirmed; any other case results in a failed confirmation.
 +
#After the expiry of the voting period, a bureaucrat shall confirm the vote counts and the voting result and proceed with the promotion accordingly.
  
−
Qualifying applicants must then pass the confirmation vote.
+
Note: If a former administrator who voluntarily resigned due to personal reasons (instead of community doubt or backlash) reapplies for administrator authority within 6 months of the leave, '''a bureaucrat may choose to skip the confirmation vote and reinstate the admin authority promptly'''.
−
*a vote may be started after the submission of an application to confirm the applicant. This vote lasts 7 days.
 
−
*In an administration confirmation vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be split (e.g. they must all go to "AYE" or "NAY").
 
−
*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, '''and''' when the ratio of participating active admins versus the number of active admins exceeds 2:3, the applicant will be confirmed; any other case results in a failed confirmation.
 
  
 
===Patrollers===
 
===Patrollers===
−
Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:  
+
#Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the patroller authority on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]] by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
−
#have at least 50 edits in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), at least 1 edit in the template namespace, and at least 1 edit in the category namespace. These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.  
+
#*Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust required to be confirmed.
−
#have good knowledge of the usage of wikitexts, categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
+
#An active administrator may review the applicant and grant the patroller authority promptly after confirming that the applicant meets requirments.
−
#be the main contributor of at least one article to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write articles. This article may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+
*Remember that the administrator may deny an application even if the minimum requirements are met.
−
#have at least three distinct edits that can demonstrate their ability to maintain and improve articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites; these currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.  
+
 
 +
====New Patroller Probation====
 +
#After a successful confirmation, the promoted applicant enters a 15-day '''New Patroller Probation Period''' ('''N3P'''). N3P Patrollers that have carried out expected maintenance and management workloads and met appropriate standards will, at the end of the N3P, become a formal patroller. If the applicant fails the N3P, they may not apply for patroller authority again in 30 days.
 +
#During N3P, the N3P patroller is treated as a member of their former user group before the promotion in promotion, impeachment, and proposal votes.
 +
#At the end of the N3P, the administrator responsible for the initial promotion (or, when this administrator is not available due to unforeseen circumstances, another administrator entrusted by the administrator responsible for the initial promotion or assigned by a bureaucrat) shall carry out an evaluation. The evaluation should cover these aspects:
 +
##Is this applicant actively participating in maintenance and management tasks and have not made major mistakes? See also {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patroller|萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务}} for reference.
 +
##Has this applicant triggered the {{ILP|Moegirlpedia:Block Policy|萌娘百科:方针#用户封禁政策|display=Block Policy}}, participated in any edit wars, or made any ad hominem attacks?
 +
##Has this applicant triggered any any [[#Grounds for demotion and removal|grounds for demotion and removal]] outlined below?
 +
#If a former patroller who voluntarily resigned due to personal reasons (instead of community doubt or backlash) reapplies for patroller authority within 6 months of the leave, the administrator granting the authority may choose to skip the N3P.
  
−
Qualifying applicants must then be confirmed by an administrator.
+
'''We return to translated text.'''
−
*Remember that the administrator may deny an application even if the minimum requirements were met.
 
−
*Note: since no vote is needed to confirm a patroller, the confirming administrator must carefully inspect the edit history of the applicant to make sure no edit wars, ad hominem attacks, or other acts disqualifying the applicant from serving as a patroller was committed by them in the past 1 month.
 
  
 
===Good editors===
 
===Good editors===
−
You do not have to apply for a good editor title; administrators and patrollers may grant good editor titles at their discretion to any editors that (wait for it) make good edits that require no further patrolling, or cleanup.  
+
*Administrators or patrollers may grant this role promptly after their review.
 +
Note that
 +
*If you want to obtain this role, you may apply directly to any administrator or patroller or apply directly on the public [[Talk:Discussion board|discussion board]].
 +
*Authorities granting good editor roles should provide accurate promotion reasons.
  
−
If you think you are eligible for the good editor title but do not have it, apply with any authority or on the discussion board.
+
==Grounds for demotion and removal==
−
 
 
−
==Grounds for impeachment, revocation, and removal==
 
 
'''The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.'''
 
'''The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.'''
−
*Impeachment, revocation, or removal should be carried out at the target user's home wiki. Impeachment, revocation, or removal at one wiki is not a necessary nor a sufficient ground for impeachment, revocation, or removal at another wiki. <ref>For example, a user granted patroller status in Chinese Moegirlpedia should not be impeached in English Moegirlpedia; an English Moegirlpedia administrator cannot lose their power due to inaction in Chinese Moegirlpedia; and a dual authority that lost their power in Chinese Moegirlpedia do not necessarily lose their English Moegirlpedia authority unless they are also eligible for removal of authority here.</ref>
+
*Any action for demotion, impeachment, or removal should follow the '''Principle of Locality''': they should be carried out at the target user's home wiki (where they were first granted the status in question). Demotion, impeachment, or removal at one wiki is not a necessary nor a sufficient ground for demotion, impeachment, or removal at another wiki. <ref>For example, a user granted patroller status in Chinese Moegirlpedia should not be impeached in English Moegirlpedia; an English Moegirlpedia administrator cannot lose their power due to inaction in Chinese Moegirlpedia; and a dual authority that lost their power in Chinese Moegirlpedia do not necessarily lose their English Moegirlpedia authority unless they are also eligible for removal of authority here.</ref>
−
*The home wiki may still consider complaints by, violations in, and user group removal in another wiki in their impeachment, revocation, or removal case.
+
**The home wiki may still consider complaints by, violations in, and user group removal in another wiki in their demotion, impeachment, or removal case.
−
'''We resume with translated text.'''
+
'''We return to translated text.'''
  
 
===Bureaucrats===
 
===Bureaucrats===
−
There are currently no standard conventions for impeachment, revocation, or removal of bureaucrats.
+
There are currently no standard conventions for demotion or removal of bureaucrats.
  
 
===Administrators===
 
===Administrators===
−
#Admins that have not edited for over three months in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another admin asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
+
*The inherent administrator authority of a bureaucrat may not be deprived independent of their bureaucrat authority.
−
#*Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+
#'''Inactivity.''' Admins that have made less than 3 edits '''in over 90 calendar days''' in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another admin asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
−
#Admin may ask for temporary leave if they are or will be busy with real-life matters; admin on leave will have their authority removed. If the admin returns within one year, they only have to prove that they still qualify for the job, and the confirmation vote is waived.
+
#'''Non-Participation.''' An admin that has not participated in four consecutive votes will receive a warning.
−
#Since 4 September 2016 09:26 UTC, an admin that has not participated in four consecutive votes or 50% of votes in one year (whichever comes first) will receive a warning. If this admin cannot provide a satisfactory explanation regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to the removal of authority.
+
#*If this admin cannot provide a satisfactory explanation to the rest of the authorities regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to removal of authority.
−
#*"Votes" include proposal votes, confirmations, and impeachments.
+
#*If this admin has provided an answer but still did not participate in the next vote, they will also be subject to removal of authority.
−
#If three or more patroller or good editor statuses granted by the same administrator within 30 days were rejected by the community and impeached, revoked, or removed, the admin in question should be temporarily demoted to patroller as their standard appears to be very different from the community.
+
#*"Votes" include proposal votes, confirmation votes, and impeachment votes.
−
#Impeachment vote.
+
#'''Voluntary Resignation.'''
−
#*In an admin impeachment vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be broken apart (e.g. the 4 votes of an admin must all go to "AYE" or all go to "NAY").
+
#'''Community Rejection.''' If three or more patroller or good editor statuses granted by the same administrator were rejected by the community and removed, and the first and the third removal spans less than one year, the admin in question should be temporarily demoted to patroller as their standard appears to be very different from the community.  
−
#*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, when the ratio of active admins versus total participating voters exceeds 2:3, '''and''' when the total turnout exceeds 1/2, the admin in question will be impeached; any other case results in a failed impeachment.
+
#*The bureaucrat may assign a 15- or 30-day probation period, after which the administrator authority may be reinstated, and during which the administrator-in-probation may not apply for administrator authority.
−
#*Note added on 2 August 2017: any user who cannot vote may express their opinions, but their opinion or "vote" are not counted as effective votes, nor do they affect the turnout in any way.
+
#'''Successful Impeachment.'''
−
#Bureaucrat action for demotion or revocation.
+
#'''Bureaucrat Action''' for demotion or removal.
  
 
===Patrollers===
 
===Patrollers===
−
#Admins that have not edited for over one month in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another authority asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
+
#'''Inactivity.''' Patrollers that have made less than 3 edits '''in over 30 calendar days''' in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another authority asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
−
#*Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia, Moegirl Commons, and Moegirl Wenku.
+
#'''Non-Paticipation.''' A patroller that has not participated in four consecutive votes will receive a warning.
−
#Resignation.
+
#*If this admin cannot provide a satisfactory explanation to the rest of the authorities regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to removal of authority.
−
#Since 4 September 2016 09:26 UTC, a patroller that has not participated in four consecutive votes or 50% of votes in one year (whichever comes first) will receive a warning. If this patroller cannot provide a satisfactory explanation regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to the removal of authority.
+
#*If this admin has provided an answer but still did not participate in the next vote, they will also be subject to removal of authority.
−
#*"Votes" include proposal votes, confirmations, and impeachments.
+
#'''Voluntary Resignation.'''
−
#If three or more good editor status granted by the same patroller within 30 days were rejected by the community and impeached, revoked, or removed, the patroller in question should have their authority revoked as their standard appears to be very different from the community.
+
#'''Successful Impeachment.'''
−
#Impeachment vote.
+
#'''Bureaucrat Action''' for removal.
−
#*In a patroller impeachment vote, active admins have 4 votes, active patrollers have 2 votes, and autoconfirmed users have 1 vote. The vote may not be broken apart (e.g. the 4 votes of an admin must all go to "AYE" or all go to "NAY").
 
−
#*When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 1:1, '''and''' when the ratio of total AYE's cast versus the total vote held by the active authorities exceeds 1/4<ref>E.g. there are 9 active admins and 22 active patrollers on 20 June 2016; they hold 9*6+22*2 = 80 votes. Thus, a patroller impeachment on this day will pass this requirement if there are more than 20 ayes.</ref>, the patroller in question will be impeached; any other case results in a failed impeachment.
 
−
#*Note added on 2 August 2017: any user who cannot vote may express their opinions, but their opinion or "vote" are not counted as effective votes.
 
−
#Bureaucrat action for demotion or revocation.
 
  
 
===Good editors===
 
===Good editors===
−
#A good editor who made more than 3 mistakes requiring the authorities' help in a short period is subject to revocation of title.
+
#'''Errors.''' A good editor who made more than 3 mistakes requiring the authorities' help in a short period of time is subject to removal of role.
−
#A good editor who committed vandalism or other acts against Moegirlpedia policies is subject to revocation.
+
#'''Violation of Policies.''' A good editor who committed vandalism or other acts violating Moegirlpedia policies (including but not limited to being blocked due to violation of policy after formal warning) is subject to removal of role.
−
#Bureaucrat action for revocation.
+
#'''Bureaucrat action''' for removal.
 +
 
 +
==Removal process==
 +
Those who have met the ground for demotion or removal will be demoted or relieved by the following process.
 +
 
 +
===Bureaucrats===
 +
There are currently no process for demotion or removal of bureaucrats.
 +
 
 +
===Administrators===
 +
*Administrators that have met ground #1, 2, 3, 4, or 6 shall be promptly demoted or relieved by a bureaucrat after confirming that the ground is indeed met.
 +
*Administrators must be impeached following the impeachment process.
 +
*#Any autoconfirmed user may initiate the impeachment process.
 +
*#*If an impeachment against the same administrator is already in progress, then in principle, additional statements, evidences, or discussions should be added to the active impeachment, and no redundant impeachment should be initiated.
 +
*#*If an user initiates multiple impeachment against the same authority within one month, or if an user initiates multiple impeachment against many authorities within the same month, a bureaucrat may, after consideration of the reasonability of these impeachments, combine or reject the said impeachment and warn the said users. In serious circumstances (e.g. obviously constituting harassment), block may be instituted if warning is ignored.
 +
*#If a valid impeachment is initiated, it immediately enters a seven-day questioning period, during which the admin being impeached may respond to the impeachment, and any autoconfirmed users having the right to vote may participate in questioning. During this period, the initiator of the impeachment may withdraw it at anytime.
 +
*#After the expiry of the questioning period, an impeachment enters the voting period if it was not withdrawn. An authority shall start a formal vote using the &#123;&#123;{{ILP|Template:vote|Template:投票|display=vote}}&#125;&#125; template with a seven-day voting period and notify all active authorities using &#123;&#123;{{ILP|Template:TGSS|Template:大召唤术|display=TGSS}}&#125;&#125; (''The Great Spell of Summoning'').<br />The vote shall be counted after the expiry of the voting period by an active administrator. The user being impeached cannot vote in their own impeachment vote; all other administrators have an equivalent of two effective votes and all other active patrollers, one. <br />The impeachment vote is passed and the impeachment successful only when the AYE's are over 2/3 of the total valid votes cast, the administrator participation rate is over 2/3, '''and''' the total authorities participation rate is over 1/2. All other cases result in a failed impeachment.
 +
*#*In an administrator impeachment vote, autoconfirmed users may express their opinions but may not vote.
 +
*#The voting result shall be confirmed by a bureaucrat, and the impeached administrator shall be relieved of their authority if the vote is passed and the result is correct.
 +
 
 +
===Patrollers===
 +
*Patrollers that have met ground #1, 2, 3, or 5 shall be promptly demoted or relieved by a bureaucrat after confirming that the ground is indeed met.
 +
*Patrollers must be impeached following the impeachment process.
 +
**The process is otherwise the same as the administrator impeachment process, with changes only to the voting eligibility and passing condition outlined in #3:
 +
***Voting eligibility. The target of impeachment may not vote; all other administrators have an equivalent of four effective votes, all other active patrollers, two, and all autoconfirmed users, one.
 +
***Passing condition. The impeachment vote is passed and the impeachment successful only when the AYE's are more than the NAY's and the AYE's are over 1/4 of the total authorities voting power. All other cases result in a failed impeachment.
 +
****"Total authorities voting power" refers to the total amount of effective votes possessed by all authorities, not counting the patroller being impeached. For example, if there are 5 active administrators and 30 patrollers, then the total authorities voting power is [5×4+(30-1)×2]=78.
 +
**The voting result shall be confirmed by a bureaucrat, and the impeached patroller shall be relieved of their authority if the vote is passed and the result is correct.
  
 
==Appendix==
 
==Appendix==
−
 
+
#For conventions regarding the application and removal of the bot role, see {{ILP|Project:Bots|萌娘百科:机器人}}.
−
===Voting convention===
+
#In all votes, one real person can vote only once. If clear evidence suggests that multiple accounts were used by the same person in a vote, all votes cast by these accounts are invalidated, and all these accounts are banned from future votes. The affected vote should be recounted unless it has been concluded for over 30 days.
−
#In all votes, one real person can vote only once. If clear evidence suggests that multiple accounts were used by the same person in a vote, all votes cast by these accounts are invalidated, and all these accounts are banned from future votes.  
+
#The aforementioned votes should meet the following requirements:
−
#The aforementioned votes need to meet these criteria:  
+
##{{Aye}} (<code>{{tl|aye}}</code>), {{Abstain}} (<code>{{tl|abstain}}</code>), and {{Nay}} (<code>{{tl|nay}}</code>) are the only three accepted voting template in a vote. A vote cast using any other choice or template used is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
−
##{{Aye}} (<code>{{tl|aye}}</code>), {{Abstain}} (<code>{{tl|abstain}}</code>), and {{Nay}} (<code>{{tl|nay}}</code>) are the only three accepted voting template in a vote. Any other choice or template used is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
 
 
##*'''This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.''' Use of <code>&#123;&#123;agree|AYE&#125;&#125;</code> and <code>&#123;&#123;disagree|NAY&#125;&#125;</code> by autoconfirmed users should be accepted as valid votes, but these users should be notified of this policy and discouraged from using those template representations. Authorities must use <code>&#123;&#123;aye&#125;&#125;</code> and <code>&#123;&#123;nay&#125;&#125;</code>.
 
##*'''This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.''' Use of <code>&#123;&#123;agree|AYE&#125;&#125;</code> and <code>&#123;&#123;disagree|NAY&#125;&#125;</code> by autoconfirmed users should be accepted as valid votes, but these users should be notified of this policy and discouraged from using those template representations. Authorities must use <code>&#123;&#123;aye&#125;&#125;</code> and <code>&#123;&#123;nay&#125;&#125;</code>.
−
##Voter should express in their vote the fact that they have read the issue in question and understand that their vote may affect Moegirlpedia's authority composition and/or policies. Vote without reason is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
+
##Voter should express in their vote the fact that they have read the content of the personnel issues to be adressed and understand that their vote may affect Moegirlpedia's authority composition and/or policies. A Vote without reason is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
−
##Authorities holding more than one effective vote may not split their votes. Split voting is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
+
##Individual votes may not be split; those who holds more than one effective vote also may not split their effective votes. A single voter must cast all of their effective votes towards one selection (out of {{Aye}}, {{Nay}}, or {{Abstain}}) only; split voting is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
−
##Admins and patrollers may use <code>&#123;&#123;abstain&#125;&#125;</code> to express their opinion if they think both sides do not represent their view. Abstaining votes are invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
+
##Admins and patrollers may use <code>&#123;&#123;abstain&#125;&#125;</code> to express their opinion if they think both sides do not represent their view. An abstaining vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
−
#The eligibility of participation is checked at the moment a vote starts; thus, authority status or functional titles gained '''during''' a vote does not qualify a user for participation in that vote.  
+
#The voting eligibility of a vote is determined at the moment it starts; thus, authority status or functional roles '''gained during''' a vote does not qualify a user for participation in that vote, and authority status or functional roles '''lost during''' a vote does not disqualify a user from participation in that vote. Exception is made for those who observed a user group change along with a block due to violations of policies, whose vote is invalid according to the following clause.
−
#*'''This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.''' The eligibility of participation is based on user group only and is checked at the wiki the vote is held. Users that do not hold a required user group status at English Moegirlpedia cannot use their user group status from Moegirlpedia of a different language to qualify as a voter.
+
#*'''This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.''' The eligibility of participation is determined at the wiki the vote is held. Users that do not hold a required user group status at English Moegirlpedia cannot use their user group status from Moegirlpedia of a different language to qualify as a voter.
−
#Votes are counted after a vote ends. No votes will be accepted once the vote ends; late votes are invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
+
#With respect to the importance of confirmation votes and impeachment votes, the voters in these votes who is not an authority must also meet all of the following requirements. A vote cast by a user who does not meet the following requirements is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
 +
##'''Be registered for at least 30 calendar days''' at the time the discussion thread initiating the vote was posted,
 +
##'''Be in compliance with policies''' and has no block record from when the discussion thread initiating the vote was posted to the expiry of the voting period, and
 +
##'''Be active''' at the time of the vote, defined as having at least one edits in  the Main, Template, Category, Help, or Project namespace at any one of Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
 +
#Votes are counted after the expiry of voting period. No late votes will be accepted after the expiry of voting period; late votes are invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
  
 
==Footnotes and references==
 
==Footnotes and references==
 
<references />
 
<references />

Latest revision as of 07:00, 28 June 2021

This text, "User:公的驱逐舰/Provisional Policy/User group policy", is an DRAFT of an provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia.
IT IS NOT AN ACTIVE POLICY.
It aims to be adopted by the community through administrator action.
This is a translated and adapted excerpt of the Chinese Moegirlpedia Policy. It will be updated if the original text changes.
The current translation is based on the original version 4996873, translated by User:One-Six, checked by , and approved by .
Provisional policies may have time limits and be subjected to swift change.

Overview

Until further change is implemented, Etolli[MORE]User's Talk PageUser's ContributionsUser's UploadsBlock this UserDeleted ContributionsPage MovesPatrol LogsComment LogsManage User's RightsAll CommentsCheck this User of the "Staff" functional user group will not participate in administrative works, will not be counted in voting matters, and will not be subjected to activity limitations.

The following clauses were expanded for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and may be slightly different from the original.

There are two types of user groups in English Moegirlpedia.

  1. Authoritative user groups (or "authorities") have some administrative rights within Moegirlpedia; their actions and comments are usually considered official actions and comments from Moegirlpedia.
    • Currently, only bureaucrats, administrators, and patrollers are considered authorities; they proceed from the most to least powerful in that order.
    • The more powerful authority also has the user group status and corresponding rights from all lower power authorities. E.g. an admin also has rights of a patroller, and a bureaucrat has rights of an admin and a patroller.
  2. Functional user groups (or "roles") have no administrative rights; however, they may have some nonadministrative privileges, such as having their edits automatically marked as patrolled (good editor) or the ability to use MediaWiki API to perform large amounts of automatic edits (bots). Users with functional user groups are still regular users, and their actions and comments in no way represent English Moegirlpedia (unless they are also an authority).

We return to translated text.

User group management rights

Detailed rights of different user groups are listed in Special:ListGroupRights. Only user group management rights are briefed here.

  1. Bureaucrats may grant or remove any user group status to or from any user (including themselves), regardless of their user group status.
  2. Administrators may grant patroller or good editor status.
  3. Patrollers may grant good editor status.

Overview of responsibilities

Administrators

Main page: Moegirlpedia:Administrators

As some of the most senior editors in Moegirlpedia, administrators will be the primary maintainer of several topics, usually a collection of articles revolving a common subject (e.g. a game or an anime show), throughout the site. They will build navboxes and other complicated templates, propose and maintain categories and categorization systems, and guide other user edits.

Admins will handle controversial, divisive, and sensitive issues should they arise; they will also participate in discussions throughout Moegirlpedia, notably in the Discussion board, and be the moderators of these discussions. Also, Admins will participate in votes that will decide the composition of the authorities and the rules or the future of Moegirlpedia.

Patrollers

Main page: Moegirlpedia:Patroller

As moderately or highly experienced editors, patrollers are tasked to maintain the readability of articles. They do not have to participate in all matters throughout the site, but they should bring every page they patrolled up to par even if they have no interest in the topics in those pages.

Good editors

Main page: Moegirlpedia:Goodeditor

Good editors do not have additional responsibilities save for those regarding the articles they have edited; their edits should be free of errors (that need others to fix); they don't have to make the articles perfect, but they must bring them up to par. Good editors should leave good, helpful edit notes if needed so that others can continue to improve the article.

Application requirements

The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.

  • Since the user group status is currently linked interwiki-wise, English Moegirlpedia follows the Chinese Moegirlpedia application requirements. This text should be updated whenever the corresponding Chinese policy is changed.
  • "Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites" currently include English, Chinese, and Japanese Moegirlpedia and Moegirl Commons and Moegirl Wenku. This applies to the rest of this document.

We return to translated text.

Bureaucrats

Currently, the bureaucrat authority is not open for application.

Administrators

Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:

  1. be an active patroller at the time of application.
  2. have at least 600 combined edits in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
    • These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  3. be skilled in the usage of wikitexts, categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia and have the ability to understand complicated wikitext.
  4. be the main contributor of at least ten articles to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write good articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  5. be the main maintainer of at least one topic to prove the ability to organize and manage topic-level projects. These topics may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  6. have understanding of article organizations in Moegirlpedia.
  7. have the ability to be on Moegirlpedia for at least 30 minutes per day to edit and maintain it.
  8. not be in active probation(see #Grounds for demotion and removal for details).
  9. have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed from the administrator authority, nor have made another application for such authority.

Patrollers

Applicants must meet these minimum requirements:

  1. have read through Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patrollerThis page does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: 萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务. (zh:萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务).
  2. have at least 200 combined edits in the main namespace (namespaceid=0), template namespace, and category namespace.
    • These edits must be considered legitimate; unconstructive edits solely for the purpose to meet edit count requirements are invalid. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  3. have good knowledge of the usage of wikitexts, categories, templates, and other programs, systems, and/or codes used throughout Moegirlpedia.
  4. be the main contributor of at least one article to prove proficiency in wikitext and ability to write articles. This article may be from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  5. have at least three distinct edits that can demonstrate their ability to maintain and improve articles. These edits may be cumulated from Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  6. have not done, in the past 30 days, any of the following:
  7. have not been, in the past 30 days, demoted or removed from the patroller authority, nor have made another application for such authority.

Good editors

One do not have to apply for a good editor role, nor is there set requirements. Administrators and patrollers may grant good editor roles at their discretion to any editors that (wait for it) make good edits that require no further patrolling or cleanup.

Promotion process

The following clauses were modified for the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia to better suit her public discussion system.

Bureaucrats

Currently, the bureaucrat authority has no set promotion process.

Administrators

  1. Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the administrator authority on the public discussion board by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
    • Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust and in turn enough AYE's in the confirmation vote.
  2. Other active administrators may post questions about management, authority power, and future development of Moegirlpedia during the questioning period. This period is generally 7 days starting from the submission of the application; a bureaucrat may change the length of the questioning period for each specific application at their discretion.
    • the applicant can choose an arbitrary amount of questions to answer;
    • the questioning authority may choose to ask additional questions when they get an answer, and the applicant can choose whether to answer the additional questions.
  3. After the expiry of the questioning period, a vote to confirm the applicant will be started by an active authority; the voting period lasts 7 days. All active authorities that participate in votes shall be pinged at the start of the vote.
    • After the voting period ends, an active administrator shall count the vote. In an administration confirmation vote, active admins have 4 votes and active patrollers have 2 votes. The vote may not be split (e.g. they must all go to "AYE" or "NAY").
    • When the ratio of AYE's versus NAY's exceeds 2:1, and when the ratio of participating active admins versus the number of active admins exceeds 2:3, the applicant will be confirmed; any other case results in a failed confirmation.
  4. After the expiry of the voting period, a bureaucrat shall confirm the vote counts and the voting result and proceed with the promotion accordingly.

Note: If a former administrator who voluntarily resigned due to personal reasons (instead of community doubt or backlash) reapplies for administrator authority within 6 months of the leave, a bureaucrat may choose to skip the confirmation vote and reinstate the admin authority promptly.

Patrollers

  1. Qualifying applicants must openly apply for the patroller authority on the public discussion board by starting a new discussion thread. The applicant should clearly announce the intention to apply in the title and the first sentence of their thread.
    • Applicants should provide reason and evidence that they qualify for and suits the power and responsibilities of the authority (e.g. providing related links to the edits, etc.); applicants failing to do so may find it challenging to gather trust required to be confirmed.
  2. An active administrator may review the applicant and grant the patroller authority promptly after confirming that the applicant meets requirments.
  • Remember that the administrator may deny an application even if the minimum requirements are met.

New Patroller Probation

  1. After a successful confirmation, the promoted applicant enters a 15-day New Patroller Probation Period (N3P). N3P Patrollers that have carried out expected maintenance and management workloads and met appropriate standards will, at the end of the N3P, become a formal patroller. If the applicant fails the N3P, they may not apply for patroller authority again in 30 days.
  2. During N3P, the N3P patroller is treated as a member of their former user group before the promotion in promotion, impeachment, and proposal votes.
  3. At the end of the N3P, the administrator responsible for the initial promotion (or, when this administrator is not available due to unforeseen circumstances, another administrator entrusted by the administrator responsible for the initial promotion or assigned by a bureaucrat) shall carry out an evaluation. The evaluation should cover these aspects:
    1. Is this applicant actively participating in maintenance and management tasks and have not made major mistakes? See also Moegirlpedia:Tasks of a patrollerThis page does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: 萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务. (zh:萌娘百科:巡查姬的巡查任务) for reference.
    2. Has this applicant triggered the Block PolicyThe page "Moegirlpedia:Block Policy" does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: 萌娘百科:方针#用户封禁政策. (zh:萌娘百科:方针#用户封禁政策), participated in any edit wars, or made any ad hominem attacks?
    3. Has this applicant triggered any any grounds for demotion and removal outlined below?
  4. If a former patroller who voluntarily resigned due to personal reasons (instead of community doubt or backlash) reapplies for patroller authority within 6 months of the leave, the administrator granting the authority may choose to skip the N3P.

We return to translated text.

Good editors

  • Administrators or patrollers may grant this role promptly after their review.

Note that

  • If you want to obtain this role, you may apply directly to any administrator or patroller or apply directly on the public discussion board.
  • Authorities granting good editor roles should provide accurate promotion reasons.

Grounds for demotion and removal

The following clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates.

  • Any action for demotion, impeachment, or removal should follow the Principle of Locality: they should be carried out at the target user's home wiki (where they were first granted the status in question). Demotion, impeachment, or removal at one wiki is not a necessary nor a sufficient ground for demotion, impeachment, or removal at another wiki. [1]
    • The home wiki may still consider complaints by, violations in, and user group removal in another wiki in their demotion, impeachment, or removal case.

We return to translated text.

Bureaucrats

There are currently no standard conventions for demotion or removal of bureaucrats.

Administrators

  • The inherent administrator authority of a bureaucrat may not be deprived independent of their bureaucrat authority.
  1. Inactivity. Admins that have made less than 3 edits in over 90 calendar days in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another admin asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
  2. Non-Participation. An admin that has not participated in four consecutive votes will receive a warning.
    • If this admin cannot provide a satisfactory explanation to the rest of the authorities regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to removal of authority.
    • If this admin has provided an answer but still did not participate in the next vote, they will also be subject to removal of authority.
    • "Votes" include proposal votes, confirmation votes, and impeachment votes.
  3. Voluntary Resignation.
  4. Community Rejection. If three or more patroller or good editor statuses granted by the same administrator were rejected by the community and removed, and the first and the third removal spans less than one year, the admin in question should be temporarily demoted to patroller as their standard appears to be very different from the community.
    • The bureaucrat may assign a 15- or 30-day probation period, after which the administrator authority may be reinstated, and during which the administrator-in-probation may not apply for administrator authority.
  5. Successful Impeachment.
  6. Bureaucrat Action for demotion or removal.

Patrollers

  1. Inactivity. Patrollers that have made less than 3 edits in over 30 calendar days in Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites and have not responded to another authority asking about this matter for over one week are subject to removal of authority.
  2. Non-Paticipation. A patroller that has not participated in four consecutive votes will receive a warning.
    • If this admin cannot provide a satisfactory explanation to the rest of the authorities regarding their non-participation or abstinence, they will be subject to removal of authority.
    • If this admin has provided an answer but still did not participate in the next vote, they will also be subject to removal of authority.
  3. Voluntary Resignation.
  4. Successful Impeachment.
  5. Bureaucrat Action for removal.

Good editors

  1. Errors. A good editor who made more than 3 mistakes requiring the authorities' help in a short period of time is subject to removal of role.
  2. Violation of Policies. A good editor who committed vandalism or other acts violating Moegirlpedia policies (including but not limited to being blocked due to violation of policy after formal warning) is subject to removal of role.
  3. Bureaucrat action for removal.

Removal process

Those who have met the ground for demotion or removal will be demoted or relieved by the following process.

Bureaucrats

There are currently no process for demotion or removal of bureaucrats.

Administrators

  • Administrators that have met ground #1, 2, 3, 4, or 6 shall be promptly demoted or relieved by a bureaucrat after confirming that the ground is indeed met.
  • Administrators must be impeached following the impeachment process.
    1. Any autoconfirmed user may initiate the impeachment process.
      • If an impeachment against the same administrator is already in progress, then in principle, additional statements, evidences, or discussions should be added to the active impeachment, and no redundant impeachment should be initiated.
      • If an user initiates multiple impeachment against the same authority within one month, or if an user initiates multiple impeachment against many authorities within the same month, a bureaucrat may, after consideration of the reasonability of these impeachments, combine or reject the said impeachment and warn the said users. In serious circumstances (e.g. obviously constituting harassment), block may be instituted if warning is ignored.
    2. If a valid impeachment is initiated, it immediately enters a seven-day questioning period, during which the admin being impeached may respond to the impeachment, and any autoconfirmed users having the right to vote may participate in questioning. During this period, the initiator of the impeachment may withdraw it at anytime.
    3. After the expiry of the questioning period, an impeachment enters the voting period if it was not withdrawn. An authority shall start a formal vote using the {{voteThe page "Template:vote" does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: Template:投票. (zh:Template:投票)}} template with a seven-day voting period and notify all active authorities using {{TGSSThe page "Template:TGSS" does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: Template:大召唤术. (zh:Template:大召唤术)}} (The Great Spell of Summoning).
      The vote shall be counted after the expiry of the voting period by an active administrator. The user being impeached cannot vote in their own impeachment vote; all other administrators have an equivalent of two effective votes and all other active patrollers, one.
      The impeachment vote is passed and the impeachment successful only when the AYE's are over 2/3 of the total valid votes cast, the administrator participation rate is over 2/3, and the total authorities participation rate is over 1/2. All other cases result in a failed impeachment.
      • In an administrator impeachment vote, autoconfirmed users may express their opinions but may not vote.
    4. The voting result shall be confirmed by a bureaucrat, and the impeached administrator shall be relieved of their authority if the vote is passed and the result is correct.

Patrollers

  • Patrollers that have met ground #1, 2, 3, or 5 shall be promptly demoted or relieved by a bureaucrat after confirming that the ground is indeed met.
  • Patrollers must be impeached following the impeachment process.
    • The process is otherwise the same as the administrator impeachment process, with changes only to the voting eligibility and passing condition outlined in #3:
      • Voting eligibility. The target of impeachment may not vote; all other administrators have an equivalent of four effective votes, all other active patrollers, two, and all autoconfirmed users, one.
      • Passing condition. The impeachment vote is passed and the impeachment successful only when the AYE's are more than the NAY's and the AYE's are over 1/4 of the total authorities voting power. All other cases result in a failed impeachment.
        • "Total authorities voting power" refers to the total amount of effective votes possessed by all authorities, not counting the patroller being impeached. For example, if there are 5 active administrators and 30 patrollers, then the total authorities voting power is [5×4+(30-1)×2]=78.
    • The voting result shall be confirmed by a bureaucrat, and the impeached patroller shall be relieved of their authority if the vote is passed and the result is correct.

Appendix

  1. For conventions regarding the application and removal of the bot role, see Project:BotsThis page does not exist in English Moegirlpedia yet. You may want to refer to this page on Chinese Moegirlpedia: 萌娘百科:机器人. (zh:萌娘百科:机器人).
  2. In all votes, one real person can vote only once. If clear evidence suggests that multiple accounts were used by the same person in a vote, all votes cast by these accounts are invalidated, and all these accounts are banned from future votes. The affected vote should be recounted unless it has been concluded for over 30 days.
  3. The aforementioned votes should meet the following requirements:
    1. (＋)AYE ({{aye}}), (∅)Abstain ({{abstain}}), and (－)NAY ({{nay}}) are the only three accepted voting template in a vote. A vote cast using any other choice or template used is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
      • This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates. Use of {{agree|AYE}} and {{disagree|NAY}} by autoconfirmed users should be accepted as valid votes, but these users should be notified of this policy and discouraged from using those template representations. Authorities must use {{aye}} and {{nay}}.
    2. Voter should express in their vote the fact that they have read the content of the personnel issues to be adressed and understand that their vote may affect Moegirlpedia's authority composition and/or policies. A Vote without reason is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.
    3. Individual votes may not be split; those who holds more than one effective vote also may not split their effective votes. A single voter must cast all of their effective votes towards one selection (out of (＋)AYE, (－)NAY, or (∅)Abstain) only; split voting is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
    4. Admins and patrollers may use {{abstain}} to express their opinion if they think both sides do not represent their view. An abstaining vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
  4. The voting eligibility of a vote is determined at the moment it starts; thus, authority status or functional roles gained during a vote does not qualify a user for participation in that vote, and authority status or functional roles lost during a vote does not disqualify a user from participation in that vote. Exception is made for those who observed a user group change along with a block due to violations of policies, whose vote is invalid according to the following clause.
    • This clause is added to the provisional policy of English Moegirlpedia and is not currently present in the original. It shall be kept in future updates. The eligibility of participation is determined at the wiki the vote is held. Users that do not hold a required user group status at English Moegirlpedia cannot use their user group status from Moegirlpedia of a different language to qualify as a voter.
  5. With respect to the importance of confirmation votes and impeachment votes, the voters in these votes who is not an authority must also meet all of the following requirements. A vote cast by a user who does not meet the following requirements is invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote and not counted toward the participation headcount.
    1. Be registered for at least 30 calendar days at the time the discussion thread initiating the vote was posted,
    2. Be in compliance with policies and has no block record from when the discussion thread initiating the vote was posted to the expiry of the voting period, and
    3. Be active at the time of the vote, defined as having at least one edits in the Main, Template, Category, Help, or Project namespace at any one of Moegirlpedia of any language and their sub-sites.
  6. Votes are counted after the expiry of voting period. No late votes will be accepted after the expiry of voting period; late votes are invalid and not counted, and the corresponding vote caster is treated as having not participated in this vote.

Footnotes and references

  1. ↑ For example, a user granted patroller status in Chinese Moegirlpedia should not be impeached in English Moegirlpedia; an English Moegirlpedia administrator cannot lose their power due to inaction in Chinese Moegirlpedia; and a dual authority that lost their power in Chinese Moegirlpedia do not necessarily lose their English Moegirlpedia authority unless they are also eligible for removal of authority here.
Retrieved from "https://en.moegirl.org.cn/index.php?title=User:公的驱逐舰/Provisional_Policy/User_group_policy&oldid=27984"